Could Man City's FFP Case Spark New Super League Debate? Danny Mills Cites LIV Golf as a Warning

Man City's Financial Fair Play Case and the Super League Debate

Manchester City's ongoing Financial Fair Play (FFP) controversy has reignited conversations about spending limits in football. This situation has raised questions about whether discussions around a European Super League might resurface. Former City defender Danny Mills shared his thoughts with GOAL, explaining why the Super League idea still faces major obstacles and used the example of the failed LIV Golf venture as a cautionary tale.

Background on the Super League Controversy

In spring 2021, twelve major clubs announced plans to create their own competition, aiming to expand it to 20 teams eventually. Among them were Premier League's City, Liverpool, Manchester United, Chelsea, Arsenal, and Tottenham. Fans reacted strongly against the plan, causing it to collapse quickly. Yet, clubs like Real Madrid and Juventus have not entirely abandoned the idea, keeping the threat alive.

A big challenge for any breakaway league is that players would lose eligibility for international tournaments under FIFA and UEFA, complicating transfers and player recruitment. Still, without FFP or Profit and Sustainability Regulations (PSR), wealthy owners could spend freely, something tempting for clubs like City amid their current FFP dispute involving 114 charges and possible severe penalties.

Why Players Would Reject a Super League

Mills explained that FIFA must approve any competition for players to participate in international games. Without that, players couldn't represent their countries at World Cups or European Championships. He emphasized the prestige linked to international success:

"You win the Premier League, the Champions League, you become a club legend. But win the World Cup or the Euros, and you're a national hero with honors like knighthoods. Those achievements last forever."

He pointed out that the Super League lacks staying power because international tournaments carry unmatched prestige. Past attempts by Saudi Arabia and China to launch alternative football formats failed. The best players will always want to compete internationally.

LIV Golf as an Example of Failure

The world of golf experienced a similar experiment with LIV Golf, which attracted top players with huge contracts and a new format aimed at global appeal. However, the project is now bankrupt and searching for partners, illustrating how breaking away from established competitions can fail.

Asked if LIV Golf's issues mirrored potential problems for a Super League, Mills responded:

"It hasn’t gone well. They found a short-term fix, but it collapsed. Sport thrives on unpredictability, winning, and losing. People want fair competition."

Mills highlighted the importance of relegation and promotion systems in maintaining excitement. Without stakes, matches become dull and fans lose interest. Expanding playoffs in leagues like the Championship keeps things competitive late into the season, unlike a closed Super League where some clubs may lose motivation once they miss top spots.

Current Situation and Uncertainties

Manchester City await the outcome of their FFP appeal after being found guilty of multiple breaches. Potential punishments include points deductions, transfer bans, or even expulsion from the Premier League. These developments cast doubt over league standings and titles won while the investigation continues.

Upcoming Match

• Fixture: Manchester City vs. Ipswich
• Competition: Premier League
• Date: 17 October 2026
• Time: 17:00